Hopes that the “next” election will fix SA must give way to prioritising swift global integration.

“Terms of trade” refers to price movements between what a country exports versus what it imports. Using average annual prices, an ounce of gold would buy about 20 barrels of oil each year throughout the 1980s and 1990s. That relationship became much more volatile this century. We can now confidently predict abrupt increases in volatility of many key trading relationships.

Our gold production has plunged while exports of coal and platinum metals have maintained the long-standing dominance of commodities among our exports. But while tax revenues from commodity exporting are critical for funding government expenditures, this sector won’t noticeably reduce unemployment or poverty.

The manufacturing component of our GDP has nearly halved since the early 1990s, and without sweeping policy shifts, this segment will become ever more vulnerable. While we fixate on our political developments, an expanding chorus of top economists agrees that there are core imbalances in the global economy that cannot be sustained. 

These imbalances pose major threats and opportunities. We don’t have the luxury of responding only once we have upgraded our domestic politics. Rather, only much greater global integration can ignite the hopes – and reward the energy – of the majority of SA’s young adults stranded by an economy that is as stagnant as it is isolated.

We must harness the recently expressed electoral dissatisfaction to initiate policy adjustments that provoke a virtuous cycle of economic gains that encourages additional pro-growth policy shifts. The end result – not the initial point of departure – will be a much more constructive political environment.

Meaningfully push back

One way or another the US will have to pare its fiscal deficits. As there are no indications this will happen soon, the risks will intensify. China’s growing trillion-dollar trade surplus is the opposite side of the same coin. But as China’s “involution” strategy of aggressively subsidising key sectors is threatening the industrial cores of many large economies, European politicians are beginning to meaningfully push back. 

Europe’s diverse challenges are snowballing while the politics of its largest nations are becoming increasingly polarised – exacerbating inherently splintered decision-making. It has become clear in recent months that an intense global trade war is now unavoidable.

As the ANC’s flaccid stance is that SA is non-aligned, the party will assume the posture of a victim while claiming that further de-industrialisation, such as reduced production and exporting of cars, was due to global shifts beyond their control.

Rather, we are entering a phase where there will be many valuable opportunities for nimble companies. Our economy’s routine underperformance reflects anti-competitive policies inducing isolation alongside a seeming longing to replay the early 1980s when our terms of trade were quite favourable. 

Carving out niches

High among the list of things which have changed is that across the world companies and countries are now much more likely to grow through carving out niches in global supply chains.

As the ANC’s anti-competitive policies preclude such employment-creating opportunities, our entrepreneurs are, to a very significant degree, forced to focus on opportunities within our stagnating domestic economy. If we wait until the ANC has been electorally neutered to address this, the damage will likely persist for generations.

We can’t wait until 2029 or 2034 to course correct. The ANC’s anti-business and anti-Western biases were always going to undermine SA’s development, and this has now proved to be politically unaffordable for the ANC. This must provoke economic and international relations policy pivots to support entrepreneurial-driven development of much broader exporting. The fresh messaging to investors and governments of affluent economies must be that a new commercially grounded SA is emerging. 

Of course it is extremely important to fix local governments, particularly in and around Johannesburg. Yet economic policy pivots and cancelling unaffordable foreign policy indulgences are absolutely essential. SA’s diverse centres of influence must now recognise the need to pursue much greater global integration.

We must purge our fully unrealistic hopes for some sort of best-case political outcome, reminiscent of 1994, which leads to our domestic economy rapidly alleviating poverty while creating many millions of jobs.

It is unconscionable to ignore the arithmetic impossibility of our domestic purchasing power increasing sufficiently to noticeably reduce our youth unemployment crisis. Not only is our domestic purchasing power woefully insufficient, but our economy is poorly structured to increase incomes or to support households accumulating wealth. 

More integrated

If a geographically isolated country needs to become much more integrated into global supply chains to increase jobs and accelerate development, it should act during a phase, like now, when the status quo is under siege.

We missed out when the Cold War ended and globalisation surged. Sanctions were removed but the ANC generally rejected competing globally. While auto manufacturing resembles an exception, this is only partially accurate. Companies were incentivised to hire union workers to produce cars in SA for the domestic and export markets through a scheme that increased the cost of cars for SA consumers.

High on the list of reasons we have such high youth unemployment is that only a sliver of young South African adults add value to exports. Instead of benefiting from the tremendous development gains which globalisation has produced, the ANC sought growth through exporting commodities globally and value-added goods mostly domestically and regionally. This path was always going to deliver harsh consequences, such as our current unemployment and poverty.

Today’s ANC elites are a fractious bunch yet all of them will contemplate today’s municipal coalition possibilities and fear that a 2029 national coalition government could exclude the ANC. Fixing service delivery in our major metros is a top priority but it can’t remedy the jobs crisis which is an existential threat to the ANC. Those fears must be put to good use. 

The prevailing discourse on job creation distills to: attract lots of investment capital and that will increase growth and eventually that will create a lot of jobs. This ignores, first, how our economy is structured and, second, how the global economy continues to evolve in demanding ways.

Sliding perilously

From the perspective of capital markets or in terms of sovereign debt creditworthiness, our economy is troubled but shows promise. From a development perspective, our economy is sliding perilously. This difference is largely explained by commodity exports.

As we can generate many tens of billions of dollars’ worth of hard currency each year, so long as our national government’s annual fiscal deficit remains reasonable enough, our sovereign debt credit rating should remain stable or even improve from its low level. But while mobilising huge sums of capital to increase commodity exports should increase SA’s debt rating, this path offers meagre relief to those unemployed or poor.

There is broad support for pursuing such investment-led growth via commodity exporting, as the ANC’s prevailing mix of anti-business, anti-growth and anti-Western policies undermines SA’s ability to compete at value-added exporting. Since the ANC came to power the industrial sector has declined from 24% of the economy to about 13% currently. In the absence of key policy pivots, manufacturing jobs are at risk of continuing to decline, perhaps quite sharply.

While SA’s policies have never prioritised broad prosperity or export competitiveness, only now is this triggering electoral consequences. The necessary next step is a reset of our political and economic debates.

[Image: by GoldenDayz]

The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.

If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend


Shawn Hagedorn

contributor

For 20 years, Shawn Hagedorn has been regularly writing articles in leading SA publications, focusing primarily on economic development. For over two years, he wrote a biweekly column titled “Myths and Misunderstandings” without ever lacking subject material. Visit shawn-hagedorn.com/, and follow him on Twitter @shawnhagedorn