South Africa has no shortage of political parties, many promising much the same things. With another election behind us and coalition negotiations under way, it is worth asking whether all this political choice is actually producing better government.

Nearly two weeks after the municipal elections, the parties are still arguing about who will govern with whom. I keep thinking about a purple cow. In 2019 I voted for one. Not an actual cow, obviously, although I’m not sure that would have been much worse. I voted for the Capitalist Party of South Africa. It collected 15,915 votes nationally, about 0.09 per cent, and won no seats in Parliament. Seven years later, I feel a little foolish about it.

Every election brings another crop of political parties, most promising familiar things. Competent government, less corruption, growth, water out of the taps, working streetlights, rubbish collected. Nobody campaigns for the opposite. Yet somehow each newcomer needs its own name, logo, leadership and party machinery, often over differences that are difficult to pin down.

On 4 November, 521 parties fielded 136,790 candidates for 10,526 council seats. Johannesburg’s certified proportional-representation list had 75 parties. Seventy-five. Some are community organisations concerned with specific local problems, and I have no quarrel with that. A residents’ association trying to rescue a failing neighbourhood is a different proposition from yet another national party promising to rescue the country. But do we really need so many of them?

A crowded political marketplace

Look at the 2024 national election. ActionSA and Freedom Front Plus each won six seats, the ACDP three, RISE Mzansi and BOSA two apiece, and GOOD one. RISE and BOSA each received about 0.4 per cent of the vote; GOOD about 0.2. Those three parties secured five MPs between them on roughly one per cent of the national vote. Their representatives may well do useful work. But I do wonder what five MPs spread across three parties can accomplish that they couldn’t achieve as part of something larger.

I understand why we have proportional representation. South Africans, of all people, ought to understand the dangers of excluding minorities from politics. Some smaller parties represent interests that might otherwise get very little attention. My irritation is with those chasing much the same liberal or reformist electorate, sometimes after splitting from the very same party.

There are incentives to keep the party machinery going once you win a seat. The Political Representatives Fund makes public money available to parties represented in the National Assembly or provincial legislatures. Under the rules amended in 2024, 90 per cent is distributed according to legislative representation and 10 per cent equitably among represented parties and independent representatives. The IEC reported disbursements of roughly R567 million in 2024/25. Whatever motivates the politicians involved, parliamentary representation brings resources and a degree of institutional standing, even when a party’s share of the national vote is tiny.

Consider the DA’s former stars. Herman Mashaba, Mmusi Maimane and Patricia de Lille all occupied prominent positions in the party before leaving and setting up organisations of their own. They had their reasons. The DA certainly has questions to answer about how it lost them. But there they are, now competing with people they once worked alongside, and I am not always sure the average voter could explain the differences in their programmes.

My sympathies lie more with the DA than with these smaller parties. I would like to see organisations with genuinely overlapping programmes try much harder to work with it, or with one another, rather than insist on going it alone. Part of that comes from Cape Town. Whenever I visit, the difference from Johannesburg is noticeable. The roads, public spaces and general upkeep of the city give the impression of a municipality that is actually being run. Much of the ordinary administration seems to work, which is more than I can say for Johannesburg. Of course, Cape Town has serious problems of its own, particularly with poverty, housing and inequality, but those problems do not erase what the city gets right.

Cape Town’s audit record is relevant here. It received a twentieth consecutive unqualified financial audit opinion for 2024/25, though it lost its clean audit after the Auditor-General raised procurement and supply-chain compliance findings. The city disputes those findings. No metropolitan municipality achieved a clean audit that year. 20 consecutive unqualified opinions are worth something, especially in South Africa, even if they don’t tell you whether a tap works or a road has been repaired.

Johannesburg is a good example of how frustrating all this becomes. The DA won 91 of the council’s 270 seats, while ActionSA secured a little over 40. Together they are only a few seats short of the 136 needed for a majority. Yet ActionSA could just as easily form part of an ANC-led arrangement with the EFF and MK, which would have enough seats to govern. A party that won about 5.7 per cent nationally in the municipal elections therefore finds itself with considerable influence over what happens in the country’s largest city. ActionSA has earned its support, and I wouldn’t dismiss it as another insignificant little party. But given its history with the DA, I find it frustrating that co-operation between the two should be so difficult.

Old quarrels, new negotiations

The difficulty is getting these people into the same room and keeping them there. Mashaba was quoted in an interview published on 8 November describing the prospects of working with the DA as “very slim. Very, very slim.” Yet a letter dated 7 November offered to withdraw his Johannesburg mayoral candidacy if Helen Zille withdrew hers, leaving the DA to nominate somebody else. The letter was reported on 10 November. Daily Maverick subsequently reported that the parties met on 12 November, with both sides describing the discussions as constructive. Perhaps something will come of it. But the old quarrels and the personalities are evidently part of the negotiations, along with the actual business of governing Johannesburg.

The failed Unite for Change arrangement is another case worth looking at. RISE Mzansi, BOSA and GOOD announced their intention to consolidate in October 2025 and abandoned the plan before this municipal election. Integrating three organisations was proving difficult, they said; Maimane also pointed to legal obstacles for parties already separately represented in Parliament. Fair enough. In May, however, GOOD and RISE agreed to share campaign structures and coordinate candidates while keeping their separate identities. So co-operation was possible, even if the grander plan fell apart. I would have liked to see more of it.

A colleague thinks I am blaming the wrong people. His argument is that support for the larger parties has fragmented, leaving councils where no one can govern alone. He has a point. Turnout rose from 45.9 per cent in 2021 to about 52 per cent this year, yet the IEC reported 127 hung councils at its 8 November declaration. There is a much bigger political problem here than the existence of a few two-seat parties. And if those parties disappeared tomorrow, their supporters would not all obediently vote DA. Some would choose somebody else, and some might stay at home.

Ward elections are where the cost of going it alone becomes easier to see. Whoever gets the most votes takes the ward, whether or not they have a majority. Two parties with broadly similar programmes can stand against each other, divide their support and lose to a candidate neither would have wanted. Why not at least try to agree on candidates before polling day? The alternative is another round of negotiations after the votes have been counted, usually conducted in public and not always with much dignity.

What I want to hear from these leaders is why remaining separate is worth it. Sometimes the differences will be real and important. Sometimes, I suspect, the explanation will be much less impressive. Voters ought to ask that question more often. I certainly wish I had asked a few more questions before voting for my purple cow. I liked that someone new was having a go. At the time, that seemed reason enough.

[Image: Julie Star/Envato]

The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.

If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend.


Peter Swanepoel

contributor

Peter Swanepoel is a historian and writer affiliated with the University of Johannesburg’s History Department, where he works under the supervision of Professor Thembisa Waetjen. His research focuses on the politics and institutional cultures of South African cycling under apartheid. He is the co-author of The Daisy Spy Ring: How South African Intelligence Agents Infiltrated and Disrupted the SA Communist Party (Naledi, 2025) and is currently completing doctoral research with funding from the National Research Foundation. He also writes on politics, history, and society, with an emphasis on institutional analysis, historical context, and moral clarity.