The ANC and ActionSA, and the smaller comrade parties, are ganging up to keep the DA out of power.
For the past two weeks since the local government elections, SA’s political parties have been locked in coalition talks, but now the prospect of a doomsday coalition to keep the DA from power in Gauteng municipalities and metros looms large.
ActionSA is emerging as the kingmaker and the wrecker of reform and turnaround chances in Gauteng metros. The party’s leader Herman Mashaba has signalled that ActionSA is about to join the doomsday coalition of the ANC, EFF, and MK that the DA wanted to keep out of national government. Likely additions to this gang coalition are the Communists and the Patriotic Alliance.
Rather than looking to be part of potential turnarounds, the ANC, ActionSA and the comrades have decided to adopt the cynical route and allow the cadres to enjoy a five-year final heyday. The alternative would be to look to being part of a DA-led turnaround, which would allow them to campaign in the national elections in 2029 on the basis that they were an integral part of the recovery of the Gauteng metros.
So far there are no declared deals, but ActionSA and the ANC, and the smaller comrade parties, the EFF, MK and the Communists and a few of the rats-and-mice parties are intent on preventing the DA from gaining power. No higher ideals about improved governance and turnarounds here. It’s about short-term deals to ensure cadres obtain the council salaries, and for their patronage networks to operate.
In all three Gauteng metros, ActionSA could help avoid a doomsday coalition by not doing a deal with the comrades and instead joining up with the DA and the Freedom Front Plus.
The messy coalition talks and the prospects of a doomsday coalition have helped weaken the Rand. Corporate SA, the National Treasury, and the bond markets are worried at the prospect of irresponsible coalitions and the dashed hopes of a turnaround leading to disaster in some of our largest cities.
Will business have a word in President Cyril Ramaphosa’s ear?
Ramaphosa, however, is now a lame duck and probably cannot do much. There appears to be no support for DA-led coalitions in the ANC.
In a less cynical world, the ANC and ActionSA could do a deal with the DA and claim to be integral to a DA-led turnaround in the interests of the voters.
Treasury will try and bring reckless councils to heel by denying bailouts and placing councils under provincial or national government authority. But that does not solve the basic problem of atrociously managed local government.
The reason ActionSA and the comrades have ganged up is that they are very scared of what new DA mayors might do. The DA is duty bound to go after corruption, tighten oversight of procurement and review all contracts.
Scared
The gang are scared that DA-led success will undermine them in 2029. Yet, if the doomsday coalition and ActionSA push Gauteng’s cities deeper into the mess, the harder and bigger the lesson that the voters will learn. This raises the possibility of pushing voters into the arms of the DA.
Voters like the idea of parties working together and would look favourably upon a DA-ANC-ActionSA coalition that resulted in a turnaround. But the ANC, ActionSA, and the smaller comrade parties are oblivious to this in their defence of patronage and real fear of what might happen under the DA.
If he were high-minded, Mashaba could set aside alleged petty slights from DA mayoral candidates, Helen Zille and Cilliers Brink. Rather than insist that Zille and Brink are dropped, Mashaba could look to the upside of cities that are turned around.
There is no way that the DA can betray the voters by dumping Zille and Brink to reach a deal with ActionSA. That would be a betrayal of DA voters.
The numbers are there for the DA to be squeezed out and that will instill voter fury among those who did not ask for the leading party across the province to be excluded from power.
In Johannesburg, the ANC and ActionSA, the EFF and MK can muster 138 seats, amounting to a majority of two seats on the council. And with the PA and a few others they would gain a few extra seats.
In Tshwane another doomsday coalition is possible – ActionSA, ANC, EFF and MK would have a majority with 109 seats on the 217-seat council. If the ANC or ActionSA were reform-minded they could agree to a coalition with the DA, which would have a majority.
ActionSA is intent on ensuring its mayoral candidate and past mayor Nasiphi Moya assumes office. She is the mayor who was warned that water from the Bronkhorstspruit treatment plant was not fit to drink and did not issue any warning. Making her mayor is a slap in the face of the voters, and ActionSA will be punished in later polls.
And in the other Gauteng metro, Ekurhuleni, the ANC, ActionSA, the EFF and MK could also obtain a slim majority in a deal that excludes the DA.
The parties are negotiating a global deal around coalitions and that just could result in changes in the government of national unity (GNU). Best for the ANC would be for the DA to pull out. The voters like the idea of the GNU, and if the DA is seen as uncooperative it would damage the party. But if the DA is treated unfairly and its number of cabinet posts are cut by the ANC, any pull-out would be better understood by the voters. Let the ANC and ActionSA damage themselves.
Be patient
For the DA, the lesson of 2026 is that with no coalition partners it might have to be patient and work toward achieving majorities. That is very difficult, but not impossible in a proportional representation system.
In Emfuleni, which includes Vereeniging in Gauteng, the DA won close to 41 per cent of the vote, which was the party’s best showing in a municipality in the province. That is a substantial rise of 16 percentage points from the 2021 local elections. That achievement took more than ten years of on-the-ground work in a municipality with a large majority of black voters.
The reason for the result, according to the DA’s mayoral candidate, Kingsol Chabalala, is that after years of ANC rule, “the voters want change, they want progress”.
The DA could be well positioned for 2029 and even 2031, as the gang that has kept it out of power is punished by the voters.
The gang has yet to do actual coalition deals, so much of what we are seeing might be opening-gambit noise. But it is not clear what is on the table to avert further municipal collapse over the next five years.
A loud warning from business could add pressure to avert this, but it is far from clear that the gang against the DA with their eyes on power are in a mood to hear this.
[Image: Elise Coates on Unsplash]
The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.
If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend