In the frenetic world of municipal coalition building, South Africans expect political parties to bargain over policy, budgets, and even service delivery. Instead, ActionSA’s Herman Mashaba has introduced a bitter cocktail of divine guidance, race card politics and corporate autocracy.

Enter a one-man wrecking ball into the battle for South Africa’s economic heartland.

In public interviews between 8 and 10 November, Mashaba reached for two non-starters when queried about coalitions and mayoral chains.

First came the spiritual justification.

Speaking at a post-election media briefing on 9 November, he said:

“I want South Africans to know this. I don’t want to waste my time believing that my relationship with Helen can be repaired. I don’t want to repair it. I truly don’t. God has told me it would be dangerous, and I consider her to be a very dangerous person.”

Then came the racial shortcut, in which he explicitly labelled Zille a “racist” and dismissed the broader DA as a “racist party” whose leaders treated him “like a boy”.

In an interview at the IEC’s National Results Operations Centre on 10 November, he said:

“I can’t support the racist… I will work with the DA only if they remove the racist elements. Honestly, my morality and value system say I can’t support someone I know is racist. I would be betraying Black people if I supported racists.”                                                                                                               

By adopting liberation parties’ long-standing tactic of reaching for the race card whenever political space tightens, Mashaba’s rhetoric has reached interesting lows. But personal agendas, holy vetoes and blanket slurs cannot occur in a vacuum.

It is the result of a lack of control and oversight within ActionSA structures, enabling its party leader to mount an egotistical crusade reminiscent of the 16th century divine right of kings.

Action SA’s Parliamentary Leader, Athol Trollip, has been reduced to being a Mashaba apologist, citing Mashaba’s communication style as great on context, if lacking in erudition.

Weight of the world

Michael Beaumont, the unelected National Chair of the party, must feel the weight of the world upon his adult shoulders. Beaumont was Mashaba’s Chief of Staff during his Johannesburg mayoralty, and arguably the faceless star of Johannesburg’ brief interlude of competent Metro administration.

The tragedy of ActionSA is that its interim democratic mechanisms are currently structured to fail when needed most. South Africa’s Municipal Structures Act imposes a strict 14-day deadline after an election to form councils and elect mayors.

But to rein in Mashaba’s excesses and indirect veto powers, ActionSA members would need to navigate the complexities of having an elective conference and, in terms of its latest constitution, an inaugural People’s Convention (both still to occur).

The interim processes include mobilising a 60%-member petition across nine provinces, and conducting a 70% ward branch audit.

Internal redress mechanisms may take months, while coalition deadlines tick down in days.

ActionSA’s interim constitution effectively neuters its own membership. Worse, the provisional internal governance structures seem ineffective in a real-time crisis. And political parties are not governed by the Companies Act, where a founder can sit on a board with perpetual voting shares, issuing executive decrees with little accountability to members or voters.

The structural contrast with its Democratic Alliance rivals is stark. Whatever one’s view of the DA’s leadership, the party functions as an institutional entity governed by a formal constitution.

Its coalition strategy is run by a negotiations team accountable to its Federal Executive. If a DA leader attempted to torpedo an essential municipal agreement based on personal animosity, or private conversations with a divine, this would immediately trigger institutional interventions. ActionSA possesses no such shock absorbers or braking mechanism.

Voters who supported ActionSA did so for its foundational principles: rule of law, economic pragmatism, and public accountability. They did not vote for a corporate cult of leadership in which individual ego, conversations with God or a veto would dictate the fate of a metropolis.

Personal crusades

If ActionSA cannot finalise its constitution, establish internal governance mechanisms and replace Mashaba’s destructive traits with rational policy, it shows that it is not a vehicle for saving South African cities, but merely a platform for personal crusades.

South Africa’s Constitution does not allow for the country to be governed by selective theocratic principles, yet Mashaba is no stranger to introducing Christian doctrine as an integral part of his purpose and ethic.

As he contemplates what lies ahead, he might want to consider Proverbs 16:18: “Pride goeth before destruction, and a haughty spirit before a fall.”

[Image: by africaimages]

The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.

If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend


Ron Weissenberg

contributor

Ron Weissenberg has four decades’ experience in mining, industry, equity finance and corporate governance in both executive and oversight leadership roles. In addition to mentoring aspirant entrepreneurs, Weissenberg lectures in corporate ethics and governance. He is a member of the Cape-based Accountability Group, which focuses on holding government officials and politicians to account.