A degree of pessimism has already set in after the 2026 local government elections, owing to the perfectly foreseeable and foreseen chaos around forming coalitions. But this was a truly momentous occasion that drives even a democratic sceptic like me to celebration and optimism. Here’s why.
There is nothing quite as dangerous as a bad ideology. Corruption, criminality, and incompetence have generated a lot of misery in South Africa, but compared to the annual cost to our economy and society of racial-socialist authoritarianism, it is small change. This racial-socialist ideology is the National Democratic Revolution (NDR) and its various shades of red that are found among a great many political parties and institutions.
The primary members of the NDR bloc in our politics are the African National Congress (ANC) and its breakaways after 1994, primarily the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) and uMkhonto weSizwe (MK).
For the purposes of this article, we will take every other NDR party that collected 20,000 or more votes in the 2026 elections. These parties, in addition to the above, are the South African Communist Party (SACP), African Transformation Movement (ATM), Afrika Mayibuye Movement (AMM), African Independent Congress (AIC), United Africans Transformation (UAT), and the African Content Movement (ACM).
NDR’s electoral performance
In 1994, this bloc – the ANC alone – received a combined 62.65% of the vote. Alone, the ANC bagged 58% in the 1995/6 local elections, 66.35% in the 1999 general, 59.4% in the 2000 local, 69.69% in the 2004 general, 64.8% in the 2006 local, 65.90% in the 2009 general, and 61.9% in the 2011 local.
Then, the breakaways began. At this point, not seeing the full picture of the bloc, many analysts believed we could already begin celebrating the decline of the ANC.
In the 2014 general, the bloc together (now including the EFF and AIC) received 69.03%. In the 2016 local, 63%. In the 2019 general (with the ATM joining) it received 69.02%. In the 2021 local, 57%. In the 2024 general (now with MK, UAT, and ACM in the mix), it received 65.05%.
This has been a remarkably consistent performance for the bloc: no less than 57% of the electorate had come out to lend it their vote. With the exception perhaps of the 2021 local elections, the bloc’s dominance was never in question.
In this year’s local election, their combined share was approximately 51.4%. Other parties associated with the same broad tradition (including the Pan Africanist Congress), but sitting outside it, recorded shares below 1% each.
Relative to 2024, the ANC, EFF, and MK each recorded lower shares in 2026.
The SACP’s 2.38% was a standout performance – the lone leftist success story – but this was an ANC appendage that contested the election independently for the first time. If its performance is added back into the ANC, it still represents a decline.
Now-ism
Already, with the elections barely over, social pessimism sprouting from the mental breakdown of Herman Mashaba has now set in.
Helen Zille – who should be repeating the words “Thank you” over and over again in a profound declaration of perpetual gratitude for the huge turnout for the DA in Johannesburg – is already cynically retweeting “You didn’t vote hard enough”-type posts on social media, while The Common Sense warns of severe economic consequences should the wrong local government coalitions be constituted.
South Africans need to liberate themselves from this now-ism.
The 2026 electoral outcome is something to celebrate. Parades need to be held in recognition of it, and 4 November should be considered as an annual day of celebration to mark the unexpected collapse in the dominance of the united radical-leftist bloc. The so-called Council of the Left is even scrambling to consolidate and entrench, realising the immenseness of their defeat.
Obviously, there will be coalition chaos, and markets – fickle things – will respond fickly. This is not a result of the inadequacy of the 2026 municipal elections, but a feature of our new politics that we had better get used to sooner rather than later.
Reasons to celebrate
We have reason to be positive about this election.
The value-proposition of the NDR bloc (and even radical leftism more broadly, seen in the collapse of parties like GOOD) has been electorally rejected in a way it never has been before.
This was the first time the bloc truly fell out of its long-standing ~60-70% band. In 2021, we came to understand that the ANC itself could fall out of it, but the nagging question remained whether the toxic, tyrannical ideology of the left could also fall out of electoral favour to the point of representing only half the voting public.
The 2026 result is the affirmative answer to that question.
Promises of “free” electricity, “free” water, “free” houses, and “free” everything that are routine from these quarters, are no longer eagerly gobbled up by the electorate, but looked at with suspicion.
The tired race card is now perhaps well and truly dead as a successful mechanism of electioneering. The DA scored record support in townships, and even the Freedom Front Plus went from no support in townships whatsoever to recording 1-2% in some areas. Though Mashaba himself is an avowed race-hustler who now believes any change in municipal boundaries is Apartheid, his party and policy has never been positioned as particularly race-inclined, and it truly harmed the ANC in the townships of Gauteng.
Further, the silly worry that the United States’s newfound rationality and firmness towards the ANC and Government of National Unity (GNU) would cause a consolidation around the radical-leftist bloc has been proved to be unfounded.
Ordinary South Africans are not so outraged at the US federal government – or outraged at all, for that matter – that they turned out to give Cyril Ramaphosa and Ronald Lamola a strong mandate to carry on the present path. Political nerds will want to point out that this was a municipal election, not a general election, but ordinary voters do not quite disaggregate their politics so precisely. Foreign policy issues also proved irrelevant in the 2024 general.
This is a clear signal to civic groups that their diplomatic overtures to the United States to protect the South African populace and economy from reprisal should continue and likely amp up. Their efforts thus far have not “alienated” the ordinary people of South Africa, though it has of course alienated the increasingly tiny and marginal political elite.
We all await, of course, the 2029 general election to affirm this outcome.
The radical-leftist bloc has tended to do better in recent general elections than in municipals, but we are now already deep into a political era of “rule breaking” (to borrow from Hermann Pretorious’s recent book). While I am not confident about it, it would not surprise me in the least if the radical-leftist bloc does even worse in 2029 than it did in 2026. This would especially be the case if it overreacts now, and undoes some of the good work the electorate has recognised in the GNU.
Active and passive positivity
This all is to say that the temperature of South African politics has declined. The radical extreme on the left – for which no answer on the right exists, mercifully – that has long toxified and polluted our politics, is clearly in retreat.
The electorate, for perhaps the first time, has signalled that it seeks stable, sober, quiet politics, not extremism or discord. This is something to be very positive about.
Our positivity should not be passive, however, but active.
Negativity about this outcome is the least rational response. Anyone whose mentality is now one of “It’s all still coalition chaos with the ANC in charge” is missing the moment.
The lowering of political temperature is a new open door – an opportunity – that we need to step through.
But a mere reduction in temperature is not by itself a solution to anything. It provides breathing room and has the potential to fortify morale, but it is not by itself action.
As the coalition chaos and uncertainty is likely to increase over the coming years, it falls to ordinary communities and businesses to approach the question of municipal and social decay with renewed vigour and determination.
With a mentality of self-doing, organised commerce and community should identify the problems in their domains and go about fixing these themselves without needlessly waiting for approval, recognition, or even refunds (that might come later!).
There has never been a better time than now to roll up our sleeves and start creating the society we want from the ground up.
This is the value-proposition of community federalism that seemingly alone can arrest the decline while politicians continue to bicker about luxuries.
[Image: David Peterson from Pixabay]
The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.
If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend