Those of us who read know of CP Snow’s two cultures, or lenses, through which we view the world – the sciences and the humanities. The two cultures do not always see eye to eye, and practitioners of either are prone to disparage the other.
Scientism is the view that any phenomena we see in the world (physical, social, or cultural), have immutable discoverable and describable qualities which result in lawlike (or rational) interactions. Scientism also thinks in terms of independent entities.
An entity is a phenomenon (an atom, a rock, a stream, a human) that has describable qualities which determine how it interacts with other entities. Scientism holds that the world operates through law-like cause and effect.
An entity may be an effect of prior causes – for example, subatomic particles, atoms, water plus earth plus gravity, organic chemicals, or a spirit world. The world therefore is understandable and controllable in principle. The important assumption is that the world is regular, predictable, and understandable.
Whether causes and effects are material, natural or supernatural is less important. Christians in the early years of science believed that God was a rational being whose creation obeyed His laws, and that they were honouring Him by attempting to understand the profundity of those laws.
The cultural innovation and edifice built on that outlook is of peculiarly Western European origin. Entities that have qualities independent of their context, linear reasoning, cause and effect, prediction, control, and acting as though abstractions and ideas are real things are still defining features of western European culture that distinguish it from the rest of the world.
A popular label is WEIRD (Western, educated, industrialised, rich, and democratic) culture, even when religious West Europeans tend to see God, heaven, and hell as outside of, and higher than, the world. Those in this WEIRD culture who believe spirits and God exist, are inclined to believe that even the supernatural cannot defy logic and therefore we can grasp it.
Even the way the West does law and politics assumes the existence of principles that enable us to predict, plan for, control, change and direct our behaviour and destiny.
The rest of the world think that everything is part of one always changing Whole, and that it (especially spirits) is not knowable, law abiding or controllable. The extreme form of this view is that it is futile to attempt to control, manipulate or plan for reality. All we can do is adapt, adjust, appease, and relate to it. The future is indeterminate and unpredictable, and so we must focus on navigating immediate events. Human thought and effort have little power to change the world. The effort, knowledge and talent of a farmer or an entrepreneur is frequently discounted when there is a crop yield or business return that is ‘disproportionate.’
Fortune or bad magic
It is common to attribute this to fortune or bad magic. The non-WEIRD world frequently believe sickness and healing are the domain of the spirits. People who practice healing live a high-risk high-stakes life. They could end up as high status shamans or being accused of witchcraft. If wealth and health are mostly about establishing good relations with powerful beings it is unsurprising when the entire economy and political system operates under that assumption.
Political and economic leadership, power, and status become all about distribution and not at all about creation. It is why people vote for those who already have power, the big man, rather than a newcomer.
Until about 1100 AD the West also thought like the non-WEIRD world.
Even today there are philosophical problems around the scientific/WEIRD outlook that have long histories of intense debate. Consider the existence or nature of spirits and God, of free will, of art, and ethics. Philosophers who specialise in those areas have been with us throughout the history of philosophy and science. Do the assumptions of scientism have any relevance in those areas?
OK so we have competing cultural claims and philosophical disputes about the nature of reality. How do we resolve disagreements? One side claims the world is such that predictions are possible, and the other side denies it.
We can easily assess prediction records. The more spectacular the predictions, the more reliably and frequently they are correct, and the more control the theories enable, the more support for scientism. Of course, the more often predictions fail the greater the support for the non-scientism position.
I would go as far as to say that scientism has decisively won in the world of mathematics, physics, chemistry, and biology. I do not think anyone thinks smart phones, atomic bombs, or Musk’s launches and captures of his giant rockets, would be possible if that were not the case.
Still, what about economics, spirits, free will and art? Does the success of the natural sciences have anything to say about them at all? Francis Galton, Darwin’s cousin and one of the fathers of statistics, proposed an idea.
Bouts of prayer
Since the Bible promises that God answers prayers (“ask and it will be given”) a simple experiment comparing the outcome of bouts of prayer versus no prayer can tell us something useful. There have been dozens of studies with good controls, and all conclude that prayer makes no detectable difference to the outcome.
Other studies produce no solid signs of communication with the dead. There are ways to weasel out of those results – by, for example, arguing that God dislikes being tested and therefore will not answer those prayers. You decide. I am just saying that the scientific method can address these issues.
What about aesthetics? Is it an entirely subjective matter? Are our subjective experiences unpredictable, or are they a function of the stimulus or our own characteristics? Are there no underlying principles or rules governing art?
Can we discover principles which enable art that better meets its purpose? I argue that there are hints that this is possible. Aspects of facial features – eye size, lip fullness, nose and chin size – predict judgements of attractiveness in women.
Signals of fertility – hip curves – are associated with female attractiveness in every investigated society. So, there are objective features that increase attractiveness.
On the other hand, a study of first year college girls showed that every one of them got the most attractive vote from at least one male student. That could be support for the notion that there is nothing objective about beauty.
Similarly with landscapes and abstract art. The hypothesis that beauty is about symmetry and balance failed to hold up. Features that stimulate and retain interest seem a more promising candidate for an aesthetic principle. In other words, the visual arts are not beyond scientific scrutiny and understanding but claims that beauty or taste is objective are equivocal.
My theory is that taste is individual but there are identifiable reasons why people prefer the appearance of one thing over another. Cuisine is however an aesthetic area that is science- and formula-driven.
Aesthetic appeal
Art is of course about more than aesthetic appeal. It is also about meaning. We know that human values are not infinite. Comprehensive surveys, of value terms in English, for example, tell us there are only three or four dozen values (once we account for similar word meanings.) We can measure the importance people attach to each value.
We also know that two or three broad dimensions explain much of the variation in that importance. That knowledge allows us to predict how people will react to changes in their environment and points to what they would like to happen most.
Could we attain a meta understanding of meaning in a similar fashion? If so, artists might benefit from the findings.
For example, the effect of popular literature and film is so predictable that industries that produce them use formulas liberally. A last point on art and aesthetics; understanding how something works – the effect of a sunset, for example, or music, or poetry – does not reduce our ability to appreciate it.
Free will is an extremely contentious subject. One side says we obviously have free will because that is how we experience it, and we can choose at any moment to deliberately contemplate anything (including the non-existent or the absurd.)
Others point out that all our scientific knowledge seems to preclude it – that is, there is no room for something causeless outside the subatomic world. Here I will not enter the long and complicated philosophical debate, but I will ask why we do not exercise free will all that much?
If we can choose to be any kind of person we like, or feel anything we want, why don’t we? William James reasoned that if he had free will he could choose not to be clinically depressed. Why then is it not widely used by therapists today?
Various levers
The habit formation industry tells us that will power does not work and that we must use various levers – in other words, causes – to drive the process. The record of people who seem to succeed in choosing a dramatically different life path, like Russell Brand, is not encouraging.
When investigated, the change so often turns out to be superficial and driven by an attempt to manage increasingly negative public opinion or avoid punishment. People like Sabina in The Unbearable Lightness of Being are mythical for a reason.
Finally, to the anti-scientism crowd out there, it is not a sound strategy to dismiss a scientistic critique of one of your assumptions by doubling down on that very assumption. You must engage with the substance of that critique.
[Image: by Johnstocker]
The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.
If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend