On 12 November, the Department of Employment and Labour released a press statement on its social media pages in which it expressed concern that foreign nationals “rule the roost in workplace employment in entry-level jobs”.

According to a report by the Department’s Labour Inspection and Enforcement Services for the first semester, foreign nationals account for a higher proportion of the labour force in entry-level jobs than South African workers, in economic sectors such as agriculture, wholesale & retail, and construction.

The statement comes against the backdrop of the Department’s introduction of the Employment Services Amendment Bill [B16-2026] in May 2026, which it recently described in another press release as being “primarily aimed at strengthening the regulation of South Africa’s labour market and ensuring that employment opportunities are better protected and managed in the interests of South African workers”.

The Bill seeks to amend the Employment Services Act (14 of 2014). Among its concerning provisions is a clause that seeks to empower the Minister of Employment and Labour, after consulting the Employment Services Board and issuing a notice in the Government Gazette, to introduce sectoral quotas on the employment of foreign nationals for employers with more than ten employees.

The Department clearly also perceives foreign nationals as a threat to South Africans in the labour market, and believes that regulating foreign employment is a way to make more employment opportunities available for South Africans.

The Free Market Foundation (FMF), which has made a submission to the Portfolio Committee on Employment and Labour recommending that the Bill be withdrawn in its entirety, disagrees with the push for labour protectionism and believes that it will not address the underlying barriers to private investment, economic growth and job creation.

The failure of the existing approach

The latest unemployment figures for the third quarter, which reflect yet another increase in South Africa’s staggering unemployment rate, bear testimony to the failure of a highly restrictive labour regulatory regime, which lies at the heart of the country’s structural unemployment crisis.

For more than three decades, the Department, in the face of conflicting evidence, has stubbornly held on to harmful policy instruments such as the minimum wage, among others, in the name of establishing a wage floor and preventing the “exploitation” of South African workers.

The result has not been the protection of workers and the generation of employment on a massive scale, but the continued exclusion of millions of South Africans, particularly young, low-skilled ones, from the labour market and their confinement to enforced idleness.

On the minimum wage and exclusion

What the Department and others fail to appreciate is that, in a country like South Africa, where the skills base is low, a policy instrument such as the minimum wage functions not as a tool of protection but as a tool of exclusion from the labour market.

By raising the cost of hiring above the marginal output of low-skilled workers, the minimum wage prices these workers out of employment and only protects those who are already in the labour force.

What then happens, as we have seen, is that it incentivises South African employers to hire “illegal” foreign nationals over South Africans, whose cost of hiring is higher.

This is then erroneously interpreted as “exploitation” and a “race to the bottom”, rather than a rational and predictable response by employers seeking to keep their labour costs down and remain economically viable.

South African workers also perceive this as “exploitation”, view their exclusion from the labour market as an affront, become increasingly frustrated and begin calling to be “put first”, as we have seen through organisations such as March and March.

Labour protectionism is no solution

But regulating foreign employment is not going to meaningfully reduce unemployment in the country and create jobs on the massive scale required to absorb millions of people into the labour force.

At best, it will redistribute access to a small pool of existing jobs in favour of angry South Africans who want to be put first. At worst, it will destroy this already limited pool of jobs, as employers, faced with higher labour costs and further regulatory constraints, are forced to cut back on employment.

The only sustainable solution is to address the underlying barriers to private investment, economic growth, and job creation. It is to deregulate the labour market and create the right incentives in the economy to encourage investment, enterprise, and employment.

JSEC: The appropriate alternative

In its submission, the FMF presents its Job Seekers Exemption Certificate (JSEC) as an appropriate alternative to labour protectionism.

Under the alternative, anyone who has been unemployed for six months or longer would be eligible to apply for a certificate free of charge, at their local municipality.

The certificate would exempt its holder from all labour legislation, including the minimum wage, for a period of 24 months. It would be revocable by the holder at any time.

The JSEC is a progressive alternative because it would restore agency to South Africans who have been unemployed for extended periods while creating the right incentives in the economy for employers to hire.

Unlike the Department’s zero-sum approach of deciding who gets access to a dwindling pool of existing jobs, the JSEC would remove key barriers to commercial activity and lay the foundation for employment creation on a massive scale.

The primary beneficiaries would be millions of young, low-skilled South Africans who want to work, but are being denied entry into the labour market by a highly restrictive labour regulatory regime.

The Department needs to recognise that its concern with foreign nationals is misplaced. They are not the root cause of the country’s unemployment crisis. The real problem lies in a restrictive labour regulatory regime that excludes millions of South Africans from the labour market. If the Department is serious about meaningfully reducing unemployment, it needs to confront this reality honestly.

[Image: by Wavebreakmedia]

The views of the writer are not necessarily the views of the Daily Friend or the IRR.

If you like what you have just read, support the Daily Friend


Ayanda Sakhile Zulu

contributor

Ayanda Sakhile Zulu holds a Bachelor's degree in Political Science from the University of Pretoria and is a Policy Officer at the Free Market Foundation.